Free Printable Halloween Would You Rather Game for Teens and Adults

Would you rather live in a haunted house with friendly ghosts, or in a castle with a grumpy vampire? Once that question lands at your Halloween gathering, the debates start, the laughter follows, and nobody is checking their phone.

This free printable Halloween Would You Rather game is built for exactly that moment. It has 25 playful, family-friendly questions that work for teens and adults, so it fits a party, a classroom, a family movie night, or a quiet evening by the pumpkins. There are no scary surprises, just silly, spooky choices that get everyone talking.

What’s Included

The printable comes as three pages, designed to look great on US Letter paper:

25 Halloween Would You Rather questions with two choices each, laid out in easy-to-read rows.
A mix of themes including costumes, candy, haunted houses, pets, and a few magical powers for good measure.
A Spooky Scoreboard on the final page for up to four players.
A light, ink-friendly design so you can print it without draining your cartridges.

Here is a small taste of what your group will be debating:

Eat only candy corn for a year, or never eat Halloween candy again?
Be a zombie in a dance flash mob, or a mummy in a three-legged race?
Be invisible for one Halloween night, or fly for one Halloween night?
Drink swamp-green punch that tastes amazing or eat a gorgeous cupcake that tastes like pickles?
Have a puppy-sized pet dragon or have a pet skeleton that follows you everywhere?

How to Play

The rules are simple, which is part of the fun. Here is one easy way to play:

Gather your group. Two players is plenty, and the game works well with a big party too.
Take turns reading a question aloud. Pass the page around so everyone gets a turn as the reader.
Everyone picks a side. Vote at the same time, either by raising a hand or by pointing left for the first option and right for the second.
Explain your choice. This is where the best stories come out. Give each person a moment to defend their pick.
Keep score if you like. Use the Spooky Scoreboard and give yourself a point whenever the group correctly guesses what you would choose.

Prefer a relaxed game with no winners? Skip the scoreboard and simply enjoy the conversation. You can also turn it into a mingling icebreaker by having guests find someone who picked the opposite answer and try to change their mind.

How to Download and Print

Getting the game ready takes only a few minutes:

Download the PDF. Click the download button below to save the file to your computer.
Open the file in any PDF viewer and choose Print.
Check your settings. Select US Letter paper and set the scale to 100 percent or “Actual size” so nothing gets cut off.
Choose color or black and white. Color looks festive, but the game is still easy to read in black and white.
Print all three pages. For a sturdier game, use cardstock, or slip the pages into clear sleeves and use dry-erase markers to reuse them.

Tip: if you are printing for a larger group, make one copy for every two or three people so everyone can see the questions.

Download The Game PDF

Time to Pick Your Side

Whether you are hosting a party, planning a classroom activity, or just looking for something fun to do on October 31st, this game is an easy way to bring people together. Print it, pass it around, and see who defends the raisin house on the street with the most passion.

Download your free copy, grab your favorite Halloween snacks, and let the debates begin. Happy Halloween!